The 2025 FA Cup final between Manchester City and Crystal Palace was expected to be a showcase of top-tier football, but the match was soon engulfed in controversy after a dramatic incident involving Crystal Palace’s goalkeeper, Dean Henderson. The fallout from this pivotal moment not only altered the course of the game but also reignited fierce debates over the use and effectiveness of the Video Assistant Referee (VAR) system. The most vocal among the critics was former England star Wayne Rooney, whose post-match comments have since gone viral and fueled calls for changes to the way technology is implemented in football.
The Incident: Dean Henderson’s Handball
The controversy unfolded in the first half of the match at Wembley Stadium. As Manchester City’s attacking machine pressed forward, Erling Haaland looked poised to break free towards goal, only to be stopped by what appeared to be a deliberate handball by Dean Henderson well outside his penalty area. The incident seemed clear-cut on live television, with replays showing Henderson reaching out to block the ball with his hand in an attempt to deny Haaland a possible goal-scoring opportunity.
Despite the visible evidence, the on-field referee initially did not issue a red card. The incident was promptly reviewed by VAR, with millions watching in anticipation of a match-defining decision. However, to the astonishment of fans, pundits, and players alike, the VAR officials decided that Henderson’s action did not meet the criteria for an “obvious goal-scoring opportunity,” a requirement for issuing a straight red card under current FIFA rules. The goalkeeper received only a yellow card, and play continued.
Wayne Rooney’s Outburst: “Get Rid of VAR”
Wayne Rooney, working as a pundit for the match broadcast, was quick to express his disbelief and frustration at the decision. In a passionate post-match rant, Rooney declared, “Just get rid of VAR.” He argued that the system, instead of correcting clear and obvious errors, was compounding confusion and denying fans and players fair outcomes. Rooney insisted that Henderson’s handball was blatant and should have resulted in a red card, fundamentally altering the dynamics of the game.
Rooney’s comments struck a chord with viewers who have grown weary of VAR’s frequent controversies, slow decision-making, and perceived inconsistencies. The former Manchester United and England captain has never shied away from criticizing officiating standards, but his call for scrapping VAR entirely added a new dimension to the ongoing debate.
The Match: Missed Penalties and Missed Chances
The drama didn’t end with Henderson’s controversial escape. Manchester City, frustrated by the incident, pressed harder to equalize after falling behind to a well-taken goal by Crystal Palace’s Eberechi Eze in the 16th minute. The match offered another twist when City were awarded a penalty after Bernardo Silva was fouled in the box.
Much to everyone’s surprise, Erling Haaland, City’s star striker and typically their go-to penalty taker, decided not to take the crucial spot kick. Instead, he handed the responsibility to Omar Marmoush. The decision shocked the commentary team and led to speculation about Haaland’s confidence and mindset. Marmoush’s effort was expertly saved by Dean Henderson, who then stopped Haaland’s attempt on the rebound, keeping Palace’s lead intact.
Rooney, never one to hold back, criticized Haaland’s reluctance, questioning his mentality and leadership. He pointed to the assertiveness shown by football icons like Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo, suggesting that top players step up in big moments rather than shying away.
Aftermath: Palace’s Triumph, City’s Despair
Crystal Palace managed to hold on to their 1–0 lead, securing a historic victory in their 164-year history and lifting their first major trophy. The scenes at Wembley were jubilant, with Palace’s players and supporters celebrating a moment that will be forever etched in the club’s legacy. The win also ensured their qualification for the 2025–26 UEFA Europa League, a remarkable achievement for a side that has often played in the shadow of England’s elite clubs.
For Manchester City, the defeat was hard to stomach, made worse by the feeling that key moments – especially the refereeing decisions – had gone against them. The controversy over Henderson’s handball overshadowed much of the post-match analysis, with pundits, former players, and fans dissecting the rules and the role of VAR in modern football.
The Wider Debate: Is VAR Good for the Game?
The incident once again highlighted the deep divisions within the football community regarding VAR. Supporters argue that technology helps ensure correct decisions, reducing the margin for human error. Critics, however, point to incidents like Henderson’s as evidence that VAR often introduces more confusion and controversy than it resolves.
Wayne Rooney’s comments encapsulated the frustration felt by many: “If we’re going to have technology, it has to work. If it keeps failing in the big moments, maybe we’re better off without it.” The FA Cup final, intended as a celebration of English football, instead served as the latest battleground in the war over how best to officiate the sport.
The 2025 FA Cup final will be remembered for more than just Crystal Palace’s triumph. It will also be a reference point in the ongoing debate over VAR and the future of football officiating. Dean Henderson’s handball, Wayne Rooney’s fiery critique, and the missed chances by Manchester City all combined to create a narrative that transcended the final scoreline. As football authorities consider the next steps for VAR, the events of Wembley will serve as a powerful reminder of both the promise and the peril of technology in the beautiful game.
About The Author
