Massachusetts has long been a stronghold for bourbon enthusiasts on the East Coast, thanks to a handful of liquor stores renowned for their extensive selections, exclusive store picks, and fair access to allocated bottles. In a recent bourbon hunting adventure around the Boston area, popular YouTuber TJ Gamble (known as Brewzle) put the community’s most hyped stores to the test. The goal: see if places like Gordon’s, Julio’s, Burlington Wine & Spirits, and others live up to their reputations for delivering quality bourbon finds without the extreme markups seen in secondary markets.
The hunt focused on greater Boston and nearby suburbs, hitting several spots recommended time and again in bourbon forums, Reddit threads, and local whiskey groups. While no ultra-rare “unicorns” like Pappy Van Winkle appeared, the trip yielded solid wins—think Weller Antique, Elijah Craig 18, and a variety of single-barrel picks—highlighting why these stores remain favorites.
Reading Liquors: A Smaller Contender
The journey kicked off at Reading Liquors, a relatively newer and smaller store north of Boston. Known occasionally for stocking bottles like Blanton’s, it didn’t deliver any major allocated hits on this visit. Still, it’s worth a stop for hunters in the area, as stock rotates and past visits have turned up surprises.
Gordon’s Fine Wines and Liquors (Waltham): Pick Heaven
Next up was Gordon’s in Waltham, a staple frequently praised for its impressive array of store-exclusive single barrels. The selection shone with unique offerings, including Old Forester single barrels, Wilderness Trail picks, and even higher-end bottles like Old Carter. No massive allocated scores here, but the variety and quality of private selections make Gordon’s a reliable spot for building a collection with bottles you won’t find everywhere.
Burlington Wine & Spirits: The Standout
Burlington Wine & Spirits emerged as one of the trip’s highlights, living up to its hype in the bourbon community. This store operates a loyalty and raffle system for harder-to-get allocations, promoting fair access. Finds included Elijah Craig Barrel Proof 18-Year, Weller Antique 107, Eagle Rare, several Orphan Barrel expressions, and an abundance of single-barrel picks from various distilleries. Commenters and locals often rave about Burlington’s accessibility and consistent stock, making it a must-visit for serious hunters.
Julio’s Liquors (Westborough): Craft and Local Focus
Further west, Julio’s Liquors in Westborough delivered on its reputation as a powerhouse. Famous for its Lock & Key Society events and deep inventory, the store featured strong options in local craft spirits alongside picks from brands like Rare Character, Willett, and Old Forester. Julio’s consistently ranks among the top in state-wide discussions for its events, tastings, and curated selections.
A Quick Swing at Gary’s Liquors
The hunt included a stop (or attempt) at Gary’s Liquors in Chestnut Hill, legendary for outstanding barrel picks and competitive pricing. While no big pulls came this time, Gary’s remains a community favorite, often cited alongside the others for its knowledgeable staff and hidden gems.
The Verdict: Hype Justified, With Realistic Expectations
Overall, the Massachusetts bourbon scene proved strong on private barrels and mid-tier allocated bottles, even if top-tier rarities stayed elusive. Standouts like a Weller Antique and a Maker’s Mark Cellar Aged bundle provided satisfying wins. These stores—Gordon’s, Burlington, Julio’s, and Gary’s—earn their buzz through quality picks, events, and fairer distribution methods compared to many states.
For anyone planning a bourbon hunt in Massachusetts, these spots top the list, especially if you’re prioritizing unique single barrels over lottery-level chases. The community continues to recommend them for good reason: consistent variety and a focus on the enthusiast experience.
About The Author
