Should you invest in REITs instead of buying a small rental flat?
In January 2026, as India’s real estate landscape continues to evolve with regulatory reforms and growing institutional interest, many investors face a key decision: should you invest in Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) or buy a small residential rental flat? For most people—particularly those seeking passive income, liquidity, and minimal hassle—REITs emerge as the superior choice in the current market.
Understanding the Options
REITs are publicly listed trusts that own and manage income-generating commercial properties, such as Grade-A office parks, retail malls, and increasingly diversified assets. In India, major players include Embassy Office Parks REIT, Mindspace Business Parks REIT, Brookfield India Real Estate Trust, and Nexus Select Trust. By law, they must distribute at least 90% of their net distributable cash flows as dividends, providing regular income.
Buying a small rental flat, on the other hand, involves direct ownership of a residential property—typically a 1- or 2-BHK apartment—to generate rental income while hoping for capital appreciation.
Current Market Realities in Early 2026
Indian REITs have shown strong performance, with the sector’s market capitalization surpassing significant milestones and overtaking peers like Hong Kong in scale. Distribution yields remain attractive, ranging from 5.1% to 7% (often 6-7% for top performers), supported by high occupancy in premium commercial assets leased to stable tenants like global capability centers (GCCs), tech firms, and BFSI companies.
In contrast, residential rental yields across India stay low. In major metros, gross yields typically hover between 2.5% and 3.5% (sometimes as low as 2-3%), while even in promising Tier-2 cities, they rarely exceed 3-5%. These figures are gross—net yields drop further after accounting for maintenance, vacancies, property taxes, and repairs.
REITs also delivered solid total returns in recent years, combining steady distributions with moderate capital appreciation (often 3-5% annually, plus price gains in strong periods). Residential properties rely more heavily on appreciation, which can be substantial in high-growth locations but remains highly uncertain and location-specific.
A Side-by-Side Comparison
- Income Generation — REITs win with higher, more consistent yields (5-7%) paid quarterly, backed by professional management and mandatory distributions. Residential flats offer lower yields, often disrupted by tenant issues or vacancies.
- Liquidity — REIT units trade on stock exchanges like shares, allowing quick entry and exit. Selling a flat can take months, involving high brokerage fees, stamp duty, and legal hurdles.
- Entry Barrier and Capital Required — Start with REITs for as little as ₹50,000–a few lakhs. A small rental flat in most cities demands ₹30-80 lakhs (plus registration and stamp duty costs), often requiring a home loan.
- Effort and Management — REITs are fully passive: professional teams handle leasing, maintenance, and operations. Owning a flat means dealing with tenants, repairs, legal disputes, society issues, and vacancies—especially challenging from locations like Shillong, where managing distant properties adds complexity.
- Diversification and Risk — REITs spread exposure across multiple premium properties and cities, reducing single-asset risk. A single flat exposes you to one location, one tenant, and local market fluctuations.
- Taxation — Distributions from REITs are taxed at your slab rate (with some components potentially tax-efficient), while rental income from a flat qualifies for a 30% standard deduction plus interest benefits on loans. Overall, REITs often feel simpler for passive investors.
- Other Factors — REITs are sensitive to interest rates and equity market volatility but benefit from India’s growing commercial real estate demand. Flats offer emotional security and potential leverage through loans, but maintenance shocks and tenant defaults can erode returns.
When REITs Are the Clear Winner
If your priorities include steady passive income, low effort, easy liquidity, and diversification, REITs are the better route in 2026. Recent reforms (effective January 1, 2026), such as reclassifying REITs as equity instruments, are expected to boost liquidity, mutual fund participation, and overall appeal. Top recommendations include Mindspace (praised for strong fundamentals and low leverage), Embassy, Brookfield, and Nexus—many experts highlight them for stable performance.
When a Small Rental Flat Might Still Appeal
Opt for a flat if you secure a great deal in a high-growth micro-market, live nearby for easy management, or prioritize long-term control and emotional ownership. In select Tier-2 pockets with faster rent growth, yields might edge higher—but challenges like tenant quality and liquidity persist.
Final Recommendation for 2026
For the average investor—especially salaried professionals or those in remote areas like Shillong—REITs outperform buying a small rental flat as an investment vehicle. They deliver superior cash flow, true passivity, and real estate exposure without the headaches.
A hybrid strategy could work well: use REITs for income generation while considering a personal home for living or legacy purposes. Ultimately, align your choice with your risk tolerance, time availability, and goals—steady income favors REITs hands-down in today’s environment.
About The Author
