Lobster Newburg: The Creamy Seafood Classic Born in 1876 at Delmonico’s
Lobster Newburg (also known as Lobster Newberg) stands as one of America’s most elegant and indulgent seafood dishes—a rich, velvety preparation that combines tender lobster meat with a luxurious sauce of cream, egg yolks, butter, and fortified wine, often finished with a touch of cayenne for subtle warmth. This decadent classic has captivated diners for nearly a century and a half, embodying the opulence of Gilded Age fine dining.
The dish’s story is tied to Delmonico’s Restaurant, the legendary New York City establishment that helped define American haute cuisine in the 19th century. Opened in the 1820s by the Delmonico brothers, the restaurant became synonymous with innovation, introducing or popularizing dishes like Delmonico steak, Eggs Benedict, and Baked Alaska. In 1876, Lobster Newburg made its debut there, quickly rising to prominence among the city’s elite.
According to the most enduring account, the creation is credited to Ben Wenberg (sometimes spelled Wenburg), a wealthy sea captain involved in the fruit trade between New York and the Caribbean, including Cuba. A regular patron of Delmonico’s, Wenberg reportedly returned from a voyage and demonstrated his special lobster recipe to Charles Delmonico, the restaurant’s manager. He prepared it tableside in a chafing dish, showcasing a novel way to pair lobster with a creamy, sherry-infused sauce.
Charles Delmonico was impressed and added the dish to the menu as Lobster à la Wenberg. The chef, Charles Ranhofer—Delmonico’s renowned culinary master from the 1860s to the 1890s—refined the recipe, enhancing its sophistication. It became an immediate favorite, drawing praise for its harmonious blend of sweet lobster and silky sauce.
The tale takes a dramatic turn with a purported falling out between Wenberg and Delmonico (accounts vary, citing an argument or dispute). In response, the dish was reportedly removed from the menu. Persistent customer demand, however, led to its reinstatement under a cleverly altered name: Lobster à la Newberg or Lobster Newberg—an anagram-like tweak swapping letters in “Wenberg” to “Newberg,” possibly nodding to “New” York while distancing it from the captain.
While this colorful narrative has been repeated for generations, food historians note it lacks definitive primary sources from the era. No surviving Delmonico menus from the 1870s list “Lobster à la Wenberg,” and similar cream-egg-sherry sauces (often called terrapin sauce) predated the dish for other ingredients. Wenberg was a real New York figure who died in 1885, but his direct role in inventing the preparation remains more legend than proven fact. Regardless, Delmonico’s is widely credited with popularizing and naming the dish in its iconic form.
Ranhofer himself documented a version in his influential 1894 cookbook, The Epicurean, describing lobster boiled, fried in clarified butter, then simmered in a reducing cream sauce with Madeira wine and seasonings. Traditional recipes often incorporated lobster roe (coral) for added flavor and color, though modern versions may omit it.
Served classically over toast points, in puff pastry vol-au-vent shells, or alongside rice, Lobster Newburg highlights the lobster’s natural sweetness without overwhelming it. Its sauce—a delicate custard-like emulsion—requires careful technique to avoid curdling, making it a hallmark of refined cooking.
Though less common on contemporary menus than in its heyday, Lobster Newburg endures as a symbol of old-school luxury. The modern Delmonico’s in New York still offers updated interpretations, sometimes with cognac, fresh herbs like tarragon, or creative accompaniments. For special occasions or when craving timeless elegance, few dishes match its creamy, sophisticated appeal—a true taste of 19th-century New York glamour.
About The Author
