India’s ambitious push to construct tunnels in the Himalayas has sparked intense debate: Are these new infrastructure projects too risky?
The Himalayas, one of the youngest and most tectonically active mountain ranges on Earth, present extraordinary challenges for tunneling. The region’s geology features unstable rock formations, high seismic activity, shear zones, squeezing ground, frequent water ingress, rockbursts, and vulnerability to landslides and avalanches. These conditions make Himalayan tunneling inherently hazardous compared to projects in more stable terrains like the Alps.
India’s tunnel-building surge is largely driven by strategic imperatives. To enhance connectivity, enable year-round access to remote border areas, and strengthen military readiness along the Line of Actual Control (LAC) with China, the government has accelerated infrastructure development. This includes all-weather roads, highway tunnels under initiatives like the Char Dham Pariyojana, and additional border-area projects involving roads, tunnels, and airfields. Hundreds of millions of dollars are being invested to counter China’s own rapid infrastructure buildup in the region.
While some projects stand as engineering successes, others have highlighted serious safety and environmental concerns. The most notorious incident remains the November 2023 collapse of the Silkyara-Barkot tunnel in Uttarakhand, part of the Char Dham project. A section caved in, trapping 41 workers underground for over 17 days before a dramatic rescue effort freed them all. The event exposed critical lapses: inadequate geological surveys, insufficient emergency provisions (such as escape tunnels or adequate ventilation), rushed construction timelines, and poor risk management in fragile Himalayan conditions.
In response, India’s Ministry of Road Transport and Highways (MoRTH) issued updated tunnel safety guidelines in late 2025, drawing lessons from Silkyara. These include stricter requirements for geological investigations, mandatory escape provisions, enhanced monitoring, and better emergency preparedness. Audits of ongoing projects were conducted, and the incident prompted broader scrutiny of tunneling practices nationwide.
Other concerns persist. Recent reports describe incidents like cracking in homes near tunnel sites (e.g., Shimla-area highway projects) and drying of natural springs due to tunneling disruptions. Environmental critics argue that unplanned hydropower dams and associated tunnels are altering fragile Himalayan landscapes, exacerbating landslide and flood risks amid intensifying climate change. In 2025, the region faced nearly continuous extreme weather events, with over 4,000 deaths linked to climate impacts, raising alarms about “hazard convergence”—where cloudbursts, landslides, subsidence, and human interventions compound disasters. Some experts warn of a potential “Himalayan ecocide” if development continues without adequate safeguards.
On the positive side, successful projects demonstrate that risks can be managed with proper engineering. The Atal Tunnel (opened in 2020), the world’s longest highway tunnel above 10,000 feet, overcame immense challenges—including fault zones and extreme weather—without major fatalities during construction. It now provides reliable all-weather access to strategic areas and is widely regarded as a triumph of modern tunneling techniques like the New Austrian Tunneling Method (NATM), rigorous monitoring, and adaptive planning.
Recent breakthroughs, such as completing sections of previously troubled tunnels (including post-2023 progress on Silkyara-related alignments), show ongoing progress. Government sources highlight tunnels as “smarter, safer, and more sustainable” alternatives to surface roads, reducing accident risks on treacherous mountain highways while boosting economic and defense connectivity.
Ultimately, the question of whether India’s new Himalayan tunnels are “too risky” hinges on execution. The geology and climate demand exceptional caution, thorough planning, and adherence to the highest safety standards. When corners are cut for speed or strategic urgency, disasters become more likely—as seen in 2023. When best practices prevail, these tunnels deliver vital benefits without unacceptable costs.
As construction continues at a rapid pace, balancing national security needs with rigorous engineering, environmental protection, and worker safety will determine whether these projects become enduring assets or cautionary tales.
About The Author
