Why You Shouldn’t Buy Physical Gold and Silver
Physical gold and silver—coins, bars, rounds, and bullion—have long appealed to investors seeking a tangible hedge against economic uncertainty, inflation, or currency devaluation. While they offer a sense of security through direct ownership, the practical realities often make them a poor choice for most people compared to alternatives like ETFs, stocks, or other diversified assets. Here’s a clear breakdown of the key reasons to reconsider purchasing physical precious metals.
1. They Generate No Income or Yield
Unlike stocks that pay dividends or bonds that provide interest, physical gold and silver produce nothing while you hold them. They sit idle, offering no cash flow or compounding returns. Over long periods, income-generating assets typically outperform non-yielding ones in total returns, especially after accounting for inflation and opportunity costs. This lack of yield is a fundamental drawback highlighted by financial advisors.
2. High Buy-Sell Spreads and Transaction Costs Eat Into Profits
When buying physical metals, you pay a premium over the spot price—often 5–15% or higher for smaller items, particularly silver. Dealers then buy back at a discount below spot, creating a spread that can consume 10–30% of your investment upfront. Add in shipping, handling fees, or sales taxes in some regions, and it becomes difficult to break even, let alone profit, unless prices rise dramatically.
3. Storage and Security Challenges (and Ongoing Costs)
You must decide where to keep your metals. Home storage risks theft, fire, or loss, and standard homeowner’s insurance often provides limited or no coverage for precious metals. A dedicated safe adds expense. Bank safety deposit boxes offer better security but come with annual fees and access restrictions. Third-party vault storage (allocated or segregated) charges 0.5–1.5% per year or flat rates, eroding returns over time. Silver is especially problematic—it’s bulkier per dollar of value, meaning $10,000 worth takes up significant space and weighs heavily (around 200–250 ounces).
4. Poor Liquidity When You Need It Most
Selling physical metals isn’t quick or seamless. You must locate a reputable dealer, verify authenticity and condition, possibly ship items, and wait for payment—sometimes days or weeks. In a market panic or crisis (a common reason people buy metals), dealers may offer lowball prices, limit purchases, or close temporarily. In contrast, gold or silver ETFs trade instantly during market hours with tight spreads and high liquidity.
5. Tax Disadvantages in Many Jurisdictions
In places like the United States, profits from physical gold and silver are often taxed as collectibles at a higher long-term capital gains rate (up to 28%) rather than the standard rate applied to stocks or ETFs. This reduces net returns compared to more tax-efficient vehicles. Storage at home may also require separate insurance, adding another layer of cost.
6. Opportunity Cost and Historical Performance Gaps
Precious metals experience strong rallies but also prolonged periods of flat or negative real returns (after inflation). They don’t always serve as perfect inflation hedges and can underperform equities during economic expansions or bull markets. Many investors buy during fear-driven peaks and sell during downturns, locking in losses. For diversification, small allocations (5–10%) might make sense, but as a core holding, they often lag broader portfolios.
7. Silver’s Extra Volatility and Practical Issues
Silver tends to be 2–3 times more volatile than gold, with sharper swings tied to industrial demand (electronics, solar, etc.) and economic cycles. Its lower value per ounce makes storage proportionally more expensive and cumbersome, amplifying the cons listed above.
Experts from sources like Ramsey Solutions, Morgan Stanley, and various investor forums emphasize that physical metals suit specific goals—such as privacy, tangible ownership, or extreme crisis preparation—better than general investing. For most seeking exposure to gold or silver prices, paper alternatives like ETFs (e.g., GLD for gold, SLV for silver) or allocated accounts deliver similar tracking with lower costs, no storage headaches, better liquidity, and often more favorable taxes.
Physical gold and silver aren’t worthless—they’ve preserved wealth through history in certain scenarios. However, for the average investor in normal or even turbulent markets, the hassles, costs, and limitations usually outweigh the benefits. If you’re drawn to them primarily for emotional security or doomsday scenarios, a modest amount might fit; otherwise, explore more efficient options first.
About The Author
