When it comes to baking the perfect brownies, one of the most debated questions among home bakers and professionals alike is whether butter or oil delivers superior results. To settle the matter, various baking experts and testers—including those from Serious Eats and Handle the Heat—have conducted side-by-side experiments, swapping one fat for the other in identical (or closely matched) recipes. The findings reveal clear differences in texture, flavor, appearance, and even how the brownies hold up over time. Here’s a detailed look at what the tests uncovered.
The Science Behind the Fats
Butter and oil both provide the essential fat that keeps brownies moist and tender, but their compositions differ significantly. Butter is about 80% fat, with the rest being water, milk solids, and sometimes salt (in salted varieties). Those milk solids contribute rich, dairy-driven flavor notes, while the water content can influence structure. Oil, typically neutral vegetable or canola, is 100% fat and remains liquid at room temperature, which affects moisture retention and chewiness.
In fair comparisons, testers often adjust quantities slightly—for instance, using a bit less oil to account for butter’s lower fat percentage—or melt the butter to ensure consistency.
Texture: Fudgy vs. Chewy
One of the most noticeable differences appears in the mouthfeel:
- Butter brownies tend to be fudgier and softer, often described as melt-in-your-mouth. The saturated fats in butter solidify as the brownies cool, creating a dense, velvety crumb that’s luxurious and classic for homemade treats.
- Oil brownies lean chewier, with denser centers and noticeably crunchier edges. The liquid nature of oil keeps the interior more pliable, mimicking the texture of many popular box-mix brownies.
In Handle the Heat’s tests, oil versions had crunchier toppings and edges, while butter produced a softer, more tender bite. Serious Eats experiments echoed this, noting that oil can push high-fat recipes toward a greasier feel if not balanced properly, but in chewy-focused formulas, it excels at delivering that satisfying pull.
Appearance: Shiny Crust or Matte Finish?
The iconic brownie top—shiny, crinkly, and paper-thin—is another battleground:
- Butter brownies frequently develop a shinier, more pronounced crinkly crust thanks to the way milk solids and water interact during baking.
- Oil brownies usually end up with a matte, flatter surface and less dramatic cracking, resembling the uniform look of commercial mixes.
Tasters in multiple rounds consistently preferred the visual appeal of butter versions for that classic, photogenic brownie aesthetic.
Flavor: Richness Wins Out
Flavor is where butter pulls ahead decisively. The dairy notes and subtle nuttiness (especially if browned) enhance the chocolate, adding complexity and depth that tasters describe as “significantly better” or more “premium” and homemade. Oil provides a cleaner chocolate taste but often feels blander or more one-note, akin to box mixes.
Serious Eats highlighted that in butter-heavy recipes, swapping to oil reduces richness, while Handle the Heat’s panel agreed butter’s flavor was the clear winner.
Moisture and Shelf Life
Oil has an edge in longevity. Since it stays liquid, oil-based brownies retain moisture longer and resist drying out over days. Butter brownies shine fresh but may firm up or stale slightly faster as the fats solidify.
The Verdict: It Depends—But There’s a Smart Compromise
Neither fat is universally “better”—it boils down to preference:
- Craving ultra-fudgy, rich, melt-in-your-mouth brownies with that shiny, crinkly top? Butter is the way to go.
- Prefer extra chew, denser texture, crunchier edges, and longer-lasting moisture? Oil delivers, especially for vegan or convenience baking.
Many experts land on the same winning strategy: use a combination of both. Half butter for superior flavor and fudginess, half oil for chew and extended moistness. This hybrid approach appears in top-rated chewy brownie recipes and often yields “the best of both worlds,” balancing richness, texture, and staying power.
So next time you bake brownies, consider your priorities. For most chocolate lovers chasing that indulgent, homemade taste, butter remains the gold standard—but a smart blend might just become your new favorite. Happy baking!
About The Author
