Germany has long been a top destination for Indian students seeking high-quality education at low or no tuition fees in public universities, promising strong career prospects in engineering, IT, and other skilled fields. With around 60,000 Indian students currently enrolled—the largest group of international students in the country—the appeal is clear. Many arrive with dreams of building a successful future, often funded by hefty education loans from India.
However, a growing number encounter a starkly different reality. Aggressive recruitment by education agents, private universities, and consultancies paints an overly optimistic picture: easy admissions, affordable living, part-time jobs to cover expenses, and a clear path to employment and residency. The truth often involves heavy debt, exploitative work conditions, and bureaucratic hurdles that threaten their stay.
One major pathway to exploitation begins with financial pressure. Students must prove sufficient funds (via blocked accounts) for visas, and living costs—especially housing in cities like Berlin or Munich—are far higher than anticipated. To survive, many turn to part-time jobs, legally limited to 20 hours per week during studies. In practice, financial necessity pushes some into the gig economy, particularly food delivery platforms such as Lieferando, Uber Eats, or similar services.
Here, exploitation is rampant. Students are often recruited through shady subcontractors or “fleets” via WhatsApp groups and informal networks. These middlemen promise quick work but deliver precarious arrangements: payments frequently below Germany’s minimum wage, often in cash to evade taxes and social security contributions; excessive hours that violate visa rules and risk permit revocation; unsafe conditions like biking in harsh weather without proper insurance; threats from employers if complaints arise; and deductions or withheld earnings with little recourse.
Platforms and subcontractors profit handsomely while riders bear the physical risks, burnout, and legal vulnerabilities. Reports highlight how this system traps indebted students in a cycle far removed from the professional “career ladder” they envisioned.
Another significant issue involves private universities, exemplified by cases at IU International University of Applied Sciences in Berlin. Hundreds of Indian students enrolled in programs marketed as full-time, on-campus experiences paid tens of thousands of euros in tuition—often funded by loans—only to face visa rejections or non-renewals. German immigration authorities (such as Berlin’s LEA) determined that certain hybrid or online-heavy formats did not qualify as genuine full-time in-person study required for student residence permits.
Students received sudden deportation notices or orders to leave, sometimes close to graduation. This has caused immense financial loss, psychological distress, and disrupted futures. The university has attributed the problem to policy shifts and stricter interpretations, while suspending new international admissions to its Berlin campus in response. Courts have upheld tighter attendance rules, leaving affected students in limbo—some forced to complete degrees remotely from India.
Broader factors compound these vulnerabilities. Limited German language proficiency and cultural barriers hinder access to better opportunities or reporting abuses. Fear of visa cancellation discourages students from complaining about illegal work hours or mistreatment. Unregulated agents in India sometimes facilitate misleading “package deals” involving questionable documents or sub-standard programs, leading to further complications like visa denials or enforcement actions.
While many Indian students thrive in Germany’s public universities, secure internships, and transition to skilled employment, the combination of financial strain, misleading recruitment, gig-economy traps, and evolving visa interpretations has ensnared others in exploitative situations.
Prospective students should rely on official sources like DAAD and German embassy websites, apply directly to universities, verify program formats thoroughly, and plan finances realistically—including realistic part-time earnings and living costs. Avoiding unregulated agents and “complete packages” is crucial to safeguarding against these risks.
About The Author
