As BRICS Debates De-Dollarisation, Why India Is Walking a Fine Line
In the ever-evolving landscape of global finance and geopolitics, few discussions have captured as much attention recently as the push by BRICS nations to reduce dependence on the US dollar. The BRICS bloc—comprising Brazil, Russia, India, China, South Africa, and its recent additions—has increasingly called for alternatives to dollar dominance in international trade and finance. Yet, among these voices, India stands out for its balanced and cautious approach, choosing pragmatic diversification over ideological alignment. As the world witnesses major shifts in the post-pandemic era, understanding India’s stance is crucial for deciphering the future of global economic order.
The Global Backdrop: Why De-Dollarisation Is Gaining Momentum
The US dollar has reigned supreme in the global financial system for decades. Over 80% of global trade and nearly 60% of foreign exchange reserves are held in dollars. This dominance gives the United States unmatched influence, allowing it to wield sanctions, control financial flows, and enjoy substantial economic advantages.
However, recent years have exposed the vulnerabilities and risks of this dollar-centric system. Western sanctions on Russia following its invasion of Ukraine, escalating US-China tensions, and the weaponisation of the dollar in geopolitical disputes have led many countries to question their reliance on the greenback. The BRICS nations, with their growing economic clout and desire for greater autonomy, have spearheaded discussions on alternative arrangements.
The push for de-dollarisation is not just about economics. It is deeply tied to questions of sovereignty, multipolarity, and the quest for a more equitable global order. For countries like Russia, which have been hit hard by Western sanctions, or China, which seeks to internationalize its own currency, reducing dollar dependence is both a defensive and offensive strategy.
BRICS and the Vision for a New Financial Order
At recent BRICS summits, including the latest in Rio de Janeiro, calls for de-dollarisation have grown louder. Proposals have included creating new payment platforms, increasing bilateral trade in local currencies, and even considering a common BRICS currency. The argument is clear: reducing exposure to the dollar would make BRICS economies more resilient to external shocks and Western political pressure.
China and Russia have been particularly enthusiastic. China sees an opportunity to promote the renminbi as a global currency, while Russia, cut off from much of the Western financial system, urgently seeks alternatives. Brazil and South Africa, meanwhile, have voiced support but face domestic constraints.
Amid this flurry of proposals, India’s response has been measured and nuanced.
India’s Strategic Calculus: Navigating the De-Dollarisation Debate
India’s global ambitions are unmistakable. As the world’s most populous country and fastest-growing major economy, India wants a greater say in global decision-making. It is deeply invested in forums like BRICS, the G20, and the United Nations. Yet, when it comes to the de-dollarisation debate, India is treading with extreme caution. Here’s why:
1. Deep Ties with the US and the Dollar System
India enjoys a robust economic and strategic partnership with the United States. The US is one of India’s largest trading partners, a major source of investment, and a key technology and defense ally. The Indian financial system is closely intertwined with the dollar-based global order. The US dollar’s liquidity and stability remain crucial for India’s trade and foreign exchange needs.
For India, abruptly moving away from the dollar would disrupt economic stability and risk straining ties with Washington. Instead, India is looking for ways to de-risk rather than de-dollarise outright.
2. Wary of New Hegemonies: The China Factor
While India supports the idea of a multipolar world, it is equally cautious about the risk of replacing one hegemon with another. China’s dominance in any new currency arrangement—especially if the yuan emerges as the alternative—would pose its own challenges for Indian sovereignty and strategic interests.
With unresolved border disputes and a complex, often tense relationship with Beijing, India is wary of deepening its financial dependence on China. It is unwilling to trade US leverage for Chinese influence, preferring a more distributed, interoperable system.
3. Pragmatism Over Idealism
India’s approach to global finance has always been pragmatic. While New Delhi has supported initiatives like the rupee-ruble payment mechanism with Russia and promoted rupee trade with smaller partners, it is acutely aware of the operational and technical hurdles in moving away from the dollar.
A BRICS currency, for instance, would require enormous groundwork: aligning monetary policies, ensuring convertibility, building cross-border payment infrastructure, and achieving mutual trust. Given the current divergences within BRICS, India believes such grand schemes are premature.
4. Diversification as De-risking
Rather than abandoning the dollar, India is investing in diversification. This includes strengthening local currency trade settlements, forging bilateral agreements with trusted partners, and exploring new financial technologies. The aim is to have more options on the table—making India less vulnerable to any single point of failure.
By promoting “interoperable options” rather than a one-size-fits-all replacement, India hopes to enhance its resilience without alienating key partners.
The Roadblocks: Internal BRICS Dynamics
Despite the public statements, the BRICS bloc is far from united in its approach to de-dollarisation. Russia and China are pushing aggressively, but their motivations are not always aligned with those of India, Brazil, or South Africa.
For instance, Brazil’s currency is not freely convertible, and South Africa’s economy is less integrated with global finance. Meanwhile, India’s concerns about China’s ambitions persist.
These internal differences make a common currency or payment platform challenging to realize in the short term. India, aware of these realities, is focusing on what is feasible now: incremental steps, bilateral agreements, and enhancing its own financial infrastructure.
US Pushback and the Global Chessboard
India’s caution is also shaped by the potential for US pushback. Recent reports of the US threatening tariffs or sanctions in response to perceived BRICS “anti-dollar” moves have not gone unnoticed. Former US President Donald Trump’s tariff threats against Brazil, for example, underscore the risks involved in moving too aggressively against the dollar system.
For India, the goal is not confrontation but strategic flexibility. By walking a fine line, India seeks to maximize its room for maneuver in a rapidly changing world.
India’s Playbook: Hedged Diversification
To sum up, India’s approach to the de-dollarisation debate is best described as “hedged diversification.” The key elements are:
- De-risking, not abandoning the US dollar.
- Avoiding new hegemonies by rejecting any arrangement that simply swaps US dominance for Chinese dominance.
- Pragmatic engagement with BRICS, focusing on realistic, incremental gains rather than grand, symbolic moves.
- Maintaining global credibility by keeping the door open to all major economic blocs.
- Acting as an all-weather partner that can work with both the West and the Global South.
India’s message to the world is clear: financial resilience comes from options, not from ideological rigidity. The dollar will remain central for now, but New Delhi is determined not to be caught off-guard by the next global shock.
Walking the Fine Line
As BRICS debates de-dollarisation and the world enters a new era of fragmentation and competition, India’s measured approach offers a blueprint for other middle powers. Rather than succumbing to the pressures of either side, India is crafting its own path—one that values flexibility, pragmatism, and above all, sovereignty.
In a world where alliances shift and economic fortunes change overnight, this fine line may well be India’s best bet for a secure and prosperous future.