Alcohol, Bureaucracy, and Business: The Strange Reality of Drinking in India
India has long had a complex relationship with alcohol—one shaped by history, politics, and cultural sensitivities. For decades, some Indian states have enforced partial or total prohibition, while others see alcohol as a crucial revenue source. This tension has produced a patchwork of laws, loopholes, and restrictions that can make ordering a drink as complicated as filing official paperwork.
Nowhere is this paradox clearer than in Gujarat, the home state of Mahatma Gandhi, where prohibition has been in place since independence. Yet, in a curious experiment, the state has allowed two bars to open inside its showcase financial hub, the Gujarat International Finance Tec-City (GIFT City). The move, designed to attract foreign investors and make the city appear globally competitive, has highlighted just how convoluted alcohol access can be in India.
GIFT City’s “Secret” Bars
When two hotel bars quietly opened inside GIFT City, it seemed like a breakthrough. For the first time in decades, alcohol was being served legally in Gujarat outside private homes and select clubs. But the reality is less liberating than it appears.
To enter, patrons need special government-issued alcohol permits. These are not easy to come by. As of mid-2025, only about 700 permits had been granted—barely enough to serve the thousands of bankers, consultants, and expatriates who populate the district.
Permit holders have become unofficial “gatekeepers.” Some, like local banker Ashutosh Singh, report receiving 15–20 calls a week from colleagues or acquaintances pleading to be taken inside. The bars themselves operate under secrecy: there are no signboards or advertisements, and entry requires showing both a permit and government-issued ID.
Even then, restrictions apply. Early curfews, police surveillance through CCTV, and constant monitoring make the experience feel less like a night out and more like stepping into a restricted facility. For hotels, the experiment has brought financial strain, as the costs of compliance and monitoring are high while customer flow remains limited.
Workarounds: Permits, Tourism Loopholes, and Medical Excuses
For those outside GIFT City, the process of legally obtaining alcohol in Gujarat remains labyrinthine. Locals can apply for a health permit, but this requires a doctor’s certificate claiming that alcohol consumption is necessary for medical reasons. Tourists can request a temporary permit, usually valid for a few days, allowing them to purchase a limited number of bottles.
The result is a system riddled with contradictions. Ordinary professionals often resort to these loopholes, while businesses find themselves juggling moral codes, customer expectations, and bureaucratic red tape.
Prohibition Elsewhere in India
Gujarat is not alone in its hardline stance. Bihar, Nagaland, Mizoram, and the Union Territory of Lakshadweep have full prohibition laws. Penalties are severe: in Gujarat, anyone found selling toxic homemade liquor faces punishment as extreme as the death penalty if it results in fatalities.
Other states enforce partial bans, especially in religiously significant towns. For instance, Madhya Pradesh banned alcohol sales in 19 pilgrimage centers in April 2025, including Ujjain and Chitrakoot, in deference to cultural sentiment.
States Moving in the Opposite Direction
While some regions tighten restrictions, others are modernizing alcohol policy. Andhra Pradesh, beginning September 2025, is introducing a new lottery-based bar licensing system designed to increase transparency and curb corruption. Under the scheme:
- Applications require a fee of ₹5 lakh.
- Annual license fees range from ₹35 lakh in small cities to ₹75 lakh in large ones.
- 10% of licenses are reserved for traditional toddy tappers at half the fee.
- Operating hours are set between 10 AM and 11 PM.
This structured approach stands in sharp contrast to Gujarat’s secretive permits, offering a glimpse of how states balance economic opportunity with social caution.
Taxation and Protests
In states where alcohol is legal, business owners face a different challenge: rising taxes. In Vidarbha (Maharashtra), bar owners have warned of indefinite shutdowns starting August 25, 2025, after excise duties surged by 60% and VAT doubled in just a year. Sales, they claim, have already dropped by 75%.
In Pune, restaurants and bars are preparing to raise menu prices by as much as 70% for mass brands and 15–20% for premium ones, sparking public backlash. Business associations warn of closures and job losses if taxes are not rolled back.
Meanwhile, in Uttar Pradesh, the government has experimented with a low-cost license—FL-7(1) at ₹4 lakh a year—meant to encourage smaller establishments to serve beer and low-alcohol drinks. But the response has been lukewarm, with only three applications filed in two months.
The Larger Paradox
Alcohol in India represents a unique paradox:
- For some states, it is a moral issue, rooted in religious or cultural beliefs.
- For others, it is a revenue lifeline, bringing in billions through excise duty.
- For consumers, it is a daily negotiation with rules, permits, and high prices.
This tension means that policies vary wildly across state borders. A traveler might find alcohol easily available in Goa’s beachfront bars but face complete prohibition upon stepping into Gujarat.
What GIFT City Reveals
The controlled experiment in GIFT City reflects the dilemmas facing modern India. On one hand, the country wants to present itself as open to global investment, welcoming multinational bankers and professionals with facilities that match London or Singapore. On the other, it remains anchored to prohibitionist ideals deeply tied to its independence movement and cultural identity.
For now, the two bars in GIFT City stand as symbols of compromise—operating under watchful eyes, catering to a select few, and highlighting the complexity of doing business in India.
If India wishes to balance morality with modernization, it will have to confront this contradiction head-on. Until then, in many places across the country, getting a drink after work will remain as challenging as negotiating a business deal.