A Kashmiri Muslim’s Testimony: Arshia Malik on the Valley’s Transformation, Radicalization, and the Coerced Silence
In a compelling and candid interview on the Bodh by Sharan Setty channel, Kashmiri Muslim intellectual Arshia Malik offered a piercing account of the valley’s journey from a liberal, integrated society to one afflicted by radical extremism, culminating in the ethnic cleansing of the Kashmiri Pandit community and the subsequent stifling of its moderate Muslim populace.
Malik’s testimony, drawn from her firsthand experience, systematically debunks common political narratives and illuminates the deep-seated cultural and legal flaws that plagued Jammu and Kashmir under its former autonomous status.
The Erosion of a Liberal Culture
Malik painted a vivid picture of life in Srinagar before the 1990s, recalling a milieu that was both open and multi-cultural. “I was 15 years old in 1990,” she stated, noting that wearing skirts and playing basketball were “very normal” activities, with “nobody ever said anything”. Crucially, the social fabric was integrated, with Kashmiri Pandits and Sikhs living as ancient neighbours alongside the Muslim population, celebrating festivals together, such as Pandits visiting on the second day of Eid.
This liberal atmosphere, however, began to change dramatically with the “advent of what we today know as Wahhabism”. The change was subtle at first, with strangers emerging in public spaces and mosques to enforce new, strict religious codes. Malik recalls preachers dictating that women must wear a veil and men must have their pajamas above the ankle.
The ideological shift was quickly backed by outright coercion from terror groups, turning social norms into deadly dictates:
- Social Life Shut Down: Pamphlets were pasted demanding that beauty parlours and cinema houses be shut down, with some cinema houses subsequently burned.
- Targeting Minorities: A hit list of prominent Kashmiri Pandits was publicly posted on electric poles and mosque doors.
- Violence Against Women: Malik cited reports of kneecapping (shooting at the knee to disable) and acid attacks on women who chose not to wear the veil.
This campaign, she explains, escalated from Srinagar to adjoining districts, with the explicit goal of forcing the population to “change your way of life”.
The Exodus and the “Coerced Silence”
Malik described the exodus of the Kashmiri Pandits as a heartbreaking event, marking what she believes was their “seventh exodus”. She noted the close, decades-long history shared by the communities, which only amplified the tragedy.
Crucially, Malik addressed the uncomfortable question often posed to the Kashmiri Muslim community: Why didn’t you stand up for them?
Her answer was direct and chilling: “They forget the fact that behind every ethnic cleansing, every family moving out of the house, a gunman would be standing there wielding an AK-47”. She emphasized that protesting was not an option in the 1990s, as anyone who questioned the terrorists or declared that “Kashmir’s future lies with India would have been shot dead as a mukbir (collaborator)”.
Today, she passionately advocates for what she calls the “silent majority” in the valley. She argues that the lack of public dissent was not due to apathy but a lack of safe space. She believes the current environment, post-2019, has created a space where people know they are safe to protest—illustrated by spontaneous protests following recent terror attacks—a development that was unimaginable in the 1990s.
The Restrictive Chains of Article 370
Malik dedicated a significant part of her testimony to the self-imposed legal and cultural restrictions that shackled the people of Jammu and Kashmir under Article 370, an arrangement that gave the region dual citizenship.
She highlighted how the former legal framework created a deeply discriminatory system: - Women’s Inheritance: “If I was a Kashmir daughter and if I did marry outside, I would lose my inheritance automatically,” she stated, adding that this loss of property rights extended to her children as well.
- Walmikis and West Pakistan Refugees: Despite living in the region for decades, Walmikis were restricted to only applying for “menial jobs”, while West Pakistan Refugees were not considered proper citizens, lacked voting rights, and were barred from government employment.
Culturally, she noted the gradual re-adoption of practices like the restrictive shuttlecock burka, which had been abandoned in the 1970s and 80s as backward. Malik says that her grandmothers would laugh at the sight of their descendants adopting the hijab, calling the trend “absurd”.
Furthermore, the legal system was governed by the Ranbir Penal Code (RPC), which was largely insular. Malik explains that it is only after the application of the Indian Penal Code (IPC)—a direct result of Article 370’s abrogation—that “a lot of liberal laws” are now automatically applied to the region.
Challenging Narratives and Internal Flaws
Arshia Malik directly confronted the persistent narrative, often propagated by “leftist media like we know today Al-Jazeera and BBC and New York Times,” which claims that India is “occupying” Kashmir.
She countered this by offering simple, practical realities: “I can own property in Indian cities as well as my own hometown. You cannot now tell me who is the occupier”. She further confirmed that Kashmiri Muslims are completely free to practice their faith, build huge mosques, and pray without state interference. The only restrictions, she noted, are for security reasons at places like the Jamia Masjid, which is often used for political purposes.
Finally, Malik identified a crucial internal flaw: “internal racism”. She revealed that some Kashmiri Muslims look down upon Indian Muslims, often due to a “fascination with… fair skin, blue eyes, light coloured hair,” and a historical self-association with Turkish descent. Dark-skinned Indian Muslims were sometimes viewed as “remnants of the old Hindu civilization” or converts.
She expressed hope that the abrogation of Article 370 has inadvertently led to a positive realization: that there are many ethnicities and kinds of Muslims in India, from a Tamil Muslim with his own interpretations of faith to others across the country. This growing understanding and exposure is, she concluded, helping to build a much-needed cultural bridge, shifting the Kashmiri consciousness from being a separate entity to being “part of a civilization, not just a country”.
Video Link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6BmQq5gwOkE