Can ‘One North East’ Redefine the Region’s Political Voice? An Editorial Scrutiny
In a significant political move, what had been whispered in journalist circles for weeks finally came to a head on Tuesday. Leaders from across the Northeast gathered at the Constitution Club of India in New Delhi to announce a new initiative—a platform for like-minded regional politicians to converge, share a vision, and forge a powerful, unified political identity for the Northeast.
The gathering featured prominent figures, including National People’s Party (NPP) leader Conrad Sangma, Monomokon from Nagaland, former BJP national spokesperson Daniel Langasa from Assam, and the scion of Tripura’s royal family, Prajyot Deb Barma. Their message was clear: “We all have similar problems, we all have similar challenges… if we have to speak for our region, then we should all shed our personal ambitions and egos and come together for the sake of our people, our communities and speak as one singular political entity.”
For many who have spent decades highlighting the myriad of issues plaguing the region, this is, on the surface, a welcome opportunity. Any concerted effort to strengthen the political voice of the Northeast at the national level is a move in the right direction. However, as with most grand political announcements in this complex region, the proposition is far from straightforward. The central question remains: Is “One North East” a meaningful political pivot, or another unfulfilled promise draped in the banner of unity?
Beyond the Coalition: The Question of Structure
Initial skepticism arises from the very structure of the announcement. While the NPP is currently the only regional national party in the Northeast, the press conference clarified that leaders like Langasa and Deb Barma are not joining the NPP. Instead, they will form a committee, with the decision to set up a new party or entity deferred for a later date. For now, it is a coalition of sorts—an alliance driven by a shared vision.
This tentative nature begs a look at history. The Northeast has been here before.
- There was a time when the entire region was under the Congress party. Did that unite the region politically or culturally? The answer is a definitive no.
- Currently, the BJP is in power in key states like Manipur, Assam, Arunachal Pradesh, and Tripura, and is in alliance in Meghalaya, Sikkim, and Nagaland. Has this brought the region together? Again, evidence suggests the opposite. The BJP, even with significant political capital, has struggled to get its own MLAs in a state like Manipur to sit together and address the violence that has ravaged the state.
If political dominance by a national party—whether Congress or BJP—failed to foster genuine regional unity, what guarantee is there that a new coalition centered on the nebulous concept of “indigenous unity” will succeed?
The Myth of Indigenity as a Solution
While the leaders rightly focused on bringing together the region’s indigenous people, the truth on the ground is far more complex. Indigenity, sadly, has not proven to be the unifying force politicians often claim it is. - Internal Clashes: Take the recent tensions at the Assam-Meghalaya border, which resulted in curfews and clashes. The communities involved—the Karbis and the Punars—are both indigenous. Did their shared heritage make it easier to solve the border dispute? No. The same question applies to the frequent border clashes between Assam and Nagaland residents. In these conflicts, who is indigenous and who is not becomes irrelevant; the dispute is paramount.
- Policy Failures: Furthermore, stronger laws meant to protect indigenous people rarely ever work as intended in practice. Look at Dimahasao, where Daniel Langasa is from. The presence of the Sixth Schedule was designed to protect the local population and resources, yet it has not managed to stop illegal mining that has ravaged the district, nor has it prevented mining and cement companies from attempting to occupy land and turn locals into cheap labour.
Indigenity is a factor, an important one, but it is demonstrably not the only factor—and often not the decisive one—in determining political or social harmony within the Northeast.
The Unending Conversation on Illegal Immigration
No pan-Northeast conversation can avoid the elephant in the room: illegal immigration. It did feature in the press conference, with leaders discussing the need to articulate views in a “more cohesive manner” regarding shared international boundaries.
Yet, talking about it is often the only action taken. Illegal immigration remains a massive issue today, just as it was a decade ago. The political reality aligns with the Hindi saying, “Hathi ke daant khane ke aur, dikhane ke aur” (The elephant has different teeth to show and different teeth to eat). The rich and powerful stand to benefit the most from unregulated, undervalued menial wage labourers. Since no one dares to speak for the vulnerable, the rich and powerful operate with impunity.
The political will to genuinely solve the illegal immigration issue falters because it runs counter to powerful economic interests. The fate of political instruments like the National Register of Citizens (NRC) in Assam and the Inner Line Permit (ILP) movement in states like Meghalaya highlights this paralysis: - States that want ILP are waiting for the Center’s approval (Meghalaya).
- States that have ILP want NRC.
- The state that has NRC (Assam) is not satisfied with the results.
Leaders like Maharaja Prajyot Deb Barma have raised this issue for decades, but the Center’s inaction continues, highlighting a fundamental state of neglect toward the region’s indigenous populations. When the autonomous council of Tripura passes a bill, it can wait for years or even decades for central approval, if it ever comes at all.
Conclusion: The Road to Unity Begins Within
It is easy to sound pessimistic, but the reality demands scrutiny. The Northeast needs to first understand and address the numerous, complex internal conflicts it faces. This will be neither easy, nor peaceful, nor quick.
The ultimate reason the Center can afford to ignore the Northeast is precisely because it is acutely aware that it takes very little to make the constituent states and communities fight against each other.
The “One North East” initiative will be a success, not because of political affinity, but if and only if the leaders commit to spending considerable time sorting out the region’s internal differences—our state borders, our resources, and our inter-community trust.
The Center can ignore the Northeast because the region speaks for itself and rarely for each other. The day a Naga starts raising the issues of a state like Mizoram and vice versa; when leaders acknowledge that merely being from a community does not guarantee they work for its interests; and the day the people realize that democracy is a powerful weapon, not merely a crutch—that is the day the Center will no longer be able to ignore the voice of the Northeast. Until then, healthy skepticism is warranted.