Why Princess Diana Was Convinced Prince Charles Plotted Her Death
The 1995 Panorama interview with Princess Diana remains one of the most explosive moments in modern royal history. Millions watched as the Princess of Wales offered unprecedented insight into her fractured marriage, uttering the famous line, “There were three of us in this marriage, so it was a bit crowded.” Yet, decades later, the interview is not primarily remembered for Diana’s candor, but for the shocking deception used by BBC journalist Martin Bashir to secure it—a deception that some argue set Diana on a path toward her tragic death two years later.
In his book Diana, author and filmmaker Andy Webb, a former BBC insider, details his 15-year investigation into the scandal, revealing secret files and the extent of the institutional cover-up that followed. His work paints a harrowing picture of a Princess manipulated by a “fantasist,” convinced her own family was plotting her demise.
The Anatomy of a Deception
Martin Bashir, then a relatively unknown current affairs journalist, managed to achieve what A-list interviewers like Barbara Walters and David Frost could not. His secret weapon was not journalistic charm, but forgery and fear.
To gain the trust of Diana’s brother, Charles Spencer, Bashir produced forged bank statements. Although the actual contents of the forgeries were not particularly significant, their mere existence served as Bashir’s “calling card,” proving to Spencer that he was a serious journalist with genuine, albeit sinister, insider sources. Spencer, who kept detailed notes of their meetings, quickly realised Bashir was “full of crap.” However, in a tragic miscalculation, he “fatally assumed” Diana had come to the same conclusion.
In the 47 days between the initial meeting and the interview’s recording, Bashir worked relentlessly on Diana, filling her head with increasingly outlandish and terrifying claims.
The Lethal Lies
The most damaging and destructive claim Bashir made was that Prince Charles was plotting to have Diana murdered. This was part of an elaborate fantasy narrative intended to convince the Princess that she was surrounded by enemies. Bashir claimed Prince Charles wished to marry the children’s nanny, Tiggy Legge-Bourke, and for this reason needed to have both Diana and Camilla Parker Bowles eliminated.
Other bizarre allegations included claims that Prince Edward had AIDS and was being treated at a London hospital, and that Prince William, then 13, had been given a James Bond-style watch capable of recording conversations. The sheer volume and audacity of these lies worked. While her brother dismissed the journalist, Diana became convinced. This manipulation, according to Webb, was “extraordinary evil.”
The BBC’s Betrayal and Cover-up
The scandal surrounding Bashir’s methods was raised almost immediately after the broadcast. Yet, the BBC launched a cover-up that lasted for decades.
Andy Webb began investigating the case in 2007, submitting Freedom of Information requests to the broadcaster. He recounts how the BBC outright lied about possessing documents related to the internal inquiries. The truth only began to surface in 2020—significantly, just 48 hours before Webb’s documentary exposing the deceit was due to air. The BBC suddenly released documents, one of which contained a false claim suggesting Charles Spencer had initiated the fraud.
This forced Spencer to contact Webb, ultimately outlining the full, scandalous story of Bashir’s death threats and list of lies. The subsequent official inquiry, led by Lord Dyson, confirmed that Bashir was deceitful and the BBC covered up his actions.
The ‘Thick Line’ to Paris
For many close to the Princess, the deception used to secure the interview was lethal. Charles Spencer and Diana’s former private secretary believe there is a “thick line” connecting the Panorama interview and the 1997 car crash in Paris.
The primary consequence of Bashir’s manipulation was psychological: having been told she couldn’t trust those around her, Diana began to cast off royal protection. She feared that those tasked with keeping her safe were part of the murder plot. This fear, sown by Bashir, meant that by the time she was in Paris, she was being protected by what Spencer deemed a “Mickey Mouse ramshackle security operation” with insufficient protection.
Spencer has stated that the consequences of the Panorama interview were lethal for his sister.
A Son’s Quest for Truth
Perhaps the most heart-wrenching aspect of the scandal is the reaction of Prince William. As a 13-year-old boy, he was “mortified” by the broadcast, which aired his mother’s innermost turmoil to the world.
Following the Dyson Report, William delivered an emotional statement, placing the blame not only on the reporter but on the institution that enabled him:
“What saddens me most is that if the BBC had properly investigated the complaints and concerns first raised in 1995, my mother would have known… She was failed not just by a rogue reporter… but by leaders at the BBC who looked the other way.”
Webb confirms that Prince William is “very, very keen” for the full truth to emerge and currently has “people on the case,” conducting a private investigation to find out exactly what happened and why the institutional cover-up was allowed to fester for so long.
Despite the proven fraud and institutional misconduct, neither Martin Bashir nor any senior BBC official has faced criminal prosecution, a fact that remains a painful question mark over the entire affair.