Why is India ‘pushing’ its citizens into Bangladesh?
Rights groups in India are sounding a grave alarm over authorities in the northeastern state of Assam who are reportedly rounding up and forcefully pushing dozens of Bengali-speaking Muslims across the border into neighboring Bangladesh. While officials claim the individuals are illegal immigrants, activists vehemently assert that many of those being deported are, in fact, Indian citizens trapped in an extralegal process designed to target a specific community.
The controversy stems from decades of political tension in Assam over the issue of alleged foreign migrants. The current government has promised to step up deportations, but the implementation has been described as ruthless, leaving tens of thousands of residents in existential dread.
The Human Cost of Deportation
The human stories behind these statistics are deeply disturbing. Chonabanu, a resident of Assam, recounts her terrifying ordeal after being briefly deported to Bangladesh. Despite having fought her case in the Supreme Court for eight years—after a local tribunal had declared her a “foreigner” a decade ago—she was called in for a routine police check, transported to a detention camp, and then forcibly pushed over the international border fence.
“They forced us through the border fence and shoved us to the other side,” she recalled, still traumatized. “They started scaring us as if they were going to fire on us. They pushed me into knee-deep water.”
The emotional toll is crippling. In a neighboring district, Azimon and her husband, Kader, have spent decades in legal battles trying to prove their Indian citizenship. Kader, whose family has generations of roots in the state, had a stroke that his family believes was caused by the stress of their contested status.
“I’m terrified. I don’t want to stay home at night,” Azimon lamented. “I’m losing my mind with worry. I haven’t been able to sleep for many nights.”Kader’s anguish is palpable as he insists on his heritage: “My grandfather and my grandmother have papers. My father is on the citizen list… I’m not a Bangladeshi. All my ancestors, my whole family is Asamis. I’m not a Bangladeshi. I’ve submitted all my documents. Still, they have made me a Bangladeshi.”
The Burden of Proof and Political Agenda
The ruling party’s defense is rooted in the claim that illegal immigrants are threatening India’s political future and that citizenship papers can be easily forged. A BJP spokesperson, Kishor Padha, stated that the government intends to thoroughly recheck citizen lists and evict more foreigners. He framed the presence of these migrants as part of a “larger plot for an immigrant takeover of Assam.”
“If they’re out to kill us, hurt our politics, our culture, to dominate us, why should we protect their human rights?” he argued.However, human rights advocate and activist Shajaha Ali strongly refutes the government’s narrative. Having personally checked the documents of over 5,000 people, he insists: “Not a single person is a Bangladeshi.”
The activist highlights the core bureaucratic barrier: most of the affected are poor, illiterate, and struggle to understand the official documents, which are often in English. Crucially, he notes that even a minor spelling or date error in vintage documents can result in a person being declared a “foreigner.”
Veteran human rights advocate Harsh Mandar corroborates the illegality of the process, describing it as “completely extralegal.” He points out that the constitutional and legal requirement is for the state to establish that a person is a foreigner before arranging a humane and civilized transfer with the destination government. Instead, the deportations are happening on a vast scale and are tied to a “larger agenda which targets India’s Muslims ideologically.”
The critical legal mechanism enabling this crisis is the shift in the burden of proof, which the Indian Supreme Court has consented to.
“It is not the state that has to establish that you are a non-citizen; it is for you to establish that you are a citizen with vintage documents going back decades and decades,” explains Mandar. This is near impossible in a country where many people are unlettered and historical records are poorly maintained or non-existent.The result is a discriminatory process where the state has weaponized the legal system against a specific demographic. Historically, both Bengali Hindus and Bengali Muslims were “othered” in Assamese society. Today, Mandar observes, the targeting is precisely focused on Bengali-speaking Muslims, an action he deems both illegal and unconstitutional, leaving countless families in dread of being forced into what is, for them, a foreign land.