Has Trump Ruined America’s Reputation Around The World?

In a wide-ranging discussion in San Francisco, Governor Gavin Newsom sat down with Ian Bremmer, the founder and president of the Eurasia Group and GZero Media, to dissect the current state of global affairs. As a leading expert on geopolitical risk, Bremmer offered a sobering analysis of the forces shaping the world, concluding that the greatest source of uncertainty today is no longer a rival power, but the United States itself.
The Unreliable Architect: The US Drives Global Uncertainty
Bremmer’s core thesis is stark: the United States, which once authored the post-World War II global order, is now the primary driver of its instability.
“The biggest thing that is so unusual in your and my histories is that the United States… is now driving the greatest level of geopolitical uncertainty,” Bremmer stated. He pointed out that this is not due to China or Russia, but the whiplash from one administration to the next and an “unwillingness to be the reliable partner” on the collective security, free-market, and rule-of-law norms the U.S. had established. This new reality is defined by unreliability and unpredictability, a state anomalous even compared to the first Trump term.
Bremmer characterized President Donald Trump’s efforts not merely as a policy shift, but as a “political revolution.” Unlike Deng Xiaoping’s successful economic revolution in China or Gorbachev’s failed political and economic one in the Soviet Union, Trump’s revolution is political, aimed at fundamentally changing the U.S. system to remove checks and balances from the presidency. This goal, Bremmer argued, explains the aggressive posture toward institutions like the media and the administrative state.
China: From Trade War to Strategic Decoupling
The conversation pivoted to the complex and evolving relationship with China. Bremmer noted that the initial trade war attempted by the Trump administration “didn’t work,” as China was unwilling to “bend the knee.” The extent to which China leveraged its strategic strength, particularly in critical minerals and rare earths, surprised the U.S. administration.
While acknowledging the economic constraints that prevent an immediate break, Bremmer asserts that the long-term US policy is moving beyond mere de-risking and toward decoupling. This is most evident in emerging technologies.
“When I think about the commanding heights of the global economy over the next five years, we’re talking about AI and advanced technologies. And these are places where what the Americans are doing and what the Chinese are doing are completely separate sets of investments. They’re not interoperable… That’s not de-risking. That’s decoupling.”
Conversely, China, witnessing the U.S. as a less reliable global leader (e.g., pulling back from USAID and COP summits), sees an opportunity to assert its own leadership. However, Bremmer cautioned that by prematurely weaponizing critical minerals, China overplayed its hand, pushing Europe, Japan, and other allies to seek alternatives and strengthen security alliances.
Escalation in the Middle East and Latin America
In the Middle East, Bremmer gave credit to the Trump administration for the success of the Abraham Accords and for securing the release of Israeli hostages through direct pressure. However, he sharply criticized the administration’s whitewashing of the Khashoggi assassination, arguing it was an unnecessary act that undermined core American values of respect for human rights.
Regarding regional stability, the prospect of peace remains distant. Saudi Arabia, despite its dramatic internal social and economic transformation, remains unwilling to join the Abraham Accords without a “clear pathway to a Palestinian state.” Looking at Lebanon, Bremmer expects Israel to inevitably resume “mowing the grass” with strikes against Hezbollah’s heavy weaponry.
The discussion then shifted to Latin America, where U.S. actions off the coast of Venezuela indicate a significant escalation. Bremmer stated he would be “stunned” if there are no direct U.S. military strikes against targets in Venezuela in the coming months. He noted that while this policy is not personally driven by Trump, it is being pushed by figures interested in countering the Maduro regime due to concerns over cocaine exports, oil sales to Cuba/China, and ideological opposition.
The Alliance Conundrum: Trust vs. Burden Sharing
Trump’s relationship with NATO and U.S. allies is a study in contradiction. Bremmer affirmed that the U.S. is “clearly better off because the Europeans are spending more” on defense, fulfilling the long-standing American demand for burden sharing.
However, this short-term gain comes with severe long-term costs. The pressure has been applied without a foundation of trust or shared values, creating deep fissures.
“The damage that’s being done to a lot of the relationships is real and is going to be persistent for a long, long time. It’s going to be hard to build [trust] back.”Bremmer stressed that the U.S. should seek “strong allies,” not just allies forced to comply. The administration’s tacit support for anti-establishment, populist forces within allied countries, such as the far-right AFD in Germany, is seen as an “own goal” that undermines the capability and long-term strength of America’s partners. The lack of friendship, trust, and shared values means alliances are reduced to transactional deals—a condition that cannot sustain a global order.
Governance Failure: AI and the Two-Tier Justice System
The final part of the discussion addressed deep-seated governance issues in the U.S., symbolized by the national reaction to AI and the Epstein files.
On Artificial Intelligence, Bremmer noted the irony that Americans are “scared” of the technology, unlike the Chinese, despite the U.S. having an incredible history of embracing frontier economies. This fear, he believes, is fundamentally a “governance issue” stemming from a lack of belief that leaders will protect them from the technology’s negative impacts. He argued that AI holds the potential to “exceed sustainable development goals” by improving global efficiency, but only if it is governed by accountable bodies and not left solely to short-term fiduciary interests of corporations.
Finally, the release of the Epstein Files was discussed as a visceral symbol of America’s political malaise.
“I think that what Epstein represents to Americans are, ‘these assholes can get away with anything.'”Bremmer views the Epstein saga as an explosive manifestation of the two-tier system of justice and accountability, confirming the long-held suspicion that people with money and power operate above the law. This sense that “something is rotten at the core” contributes to the widespread belief that the political system is unfixable, further eroding global faith in the American model.
Despite the bleak global outlook, Bremmer offered a small seed of optimism rooted in demographics. He highlighted that young people are inherently more global, skeptical, and focused on long-term issues like climate change. As they inevitably become demographically dominant, Bremmer hopes their global connectivity and disillusionment with the current political establishment will compel them to find a way to fix the system.