In a popular 2020 YouTube video that has racked up over 3 million views, personal finance expert Marko from WhiteBoard Finance dropped a counterintuitive bombshell: Don’t pay cash at car dealerships—at least not right away. The title says it all: “DON’T PAY CASH AT CAR DEALERSHIPS! (Here’s Why).”
Five years later, in late 2025, is this advice still relevant? Absolutely. Dealership business models haven’t fundamentally changed. If anything, with new car prices hovering around $50,000 and used cars near $26,000 (per Kelley Blue Book data from December 2025), smart negotiating tactics are more important than ever.
The Core Reason: Dealerships Profit Heavily from Financing
Car dealerships don’t make most of their money from simply selling vehicles. A significant chunk comes from the finance and insurance (F&I) office. Here’s how:
- Interest Rate Markups (Dealer Reserve): Dealers act as middlemen between you and lenders. They get a “buy rate” from the bank but can mark it up (typically 1-2.5%) and pocket the difference. This can add thousands in profit over the loan’s life.
- Kickbacks and Incentives: Lenders pay dealers flat fees, percentages of the loan, or bonuses for volume.
- Add-Ons: Extended warranties, gap insurance, and protection plans are high-margin products often pushed during financing discussions.
Sources like CarEdge, RealCarTips, and Experian confirm that in 2025, dealers still earn substantial backend profits from financing—often more than from the car sale itself. Telling a salesperson early that you’re paying cash signals: “No extra profit for you.” This reduces their incentive to offer the deepest discounts.
The Smart Strategy: Negotiate as If You’re Financing
- Research and Prepare: Get pre-approved for a loan from a bank, credit union, or online lender. This gives you leverage and a backup rate (current averages: ~6.6% for new cars with good credit, per Edmunds November 2025 data).
- Negotiate the Out-the-Door Price First: Focus solely on the total price (including taxes, fees). Avoid mentioning payment method until the deal is locked in.
- Reveal Cash (or Pay Off) at the End: Once you have the lowest price:
- Pay in full with a cashier’s check or wire transfer.
- Or finance briefly (even through the dealer) and pay off immediately—most loans have no prepayment penalties.
This way, the dealer anticipates financing profits during negotiations, leading to bigger discounts. Experts from CarEdge (2025 guide) and Kelley Blue Book emphasize: “Waiting to tell the dealer is crucial if you decide to pay cash.”
When Might Financing Actually Be Better?
- Low or 0% Dealer Incentives: Some manufacturers offer promotional rates you can’t beat elsewhere.
- Opportunity Cost: If rates are low (e.g., under 5-6%) and you can invest cash elsewhere for higher returns (stock market averages ~7-10% historically), keeping the loan might make sense.
- Credit Building: Responsible financing can boost your score.
But for most cash-ready buyers, the negotiation edge from “pretending” to finance wins out.
Real-World Confirmation in 2025
Recent discussions on Reddit (r/carbuying, r/personalfinance) and articles from Autoblog, Bankrate, and Clark Howard echo the same sentiment: Cash buyers often pay more because dealers prioritize financed deals. One 2025 Reddit thread called cash discounts a “myth” from decades ago.
Marko’s 2020 advice holds strong today: Even if you can pay cash, don’t announce it upfront. Negotiate aggressively as a “financing” buyer, secure the best price, then pay your way. This legal, ethical tactic can save thousands—no deception required, just savvy shopping in a system stacked toward financed profits.
Planning a car purchase? Arm yourself with pre-approval and research. You’ll drive away happier—and richer. 🚗💰
About The Author
