How to Grill Shrimp So It Turns Out Perfect Every Single Time, According to a Chef
Grilled shrimp is one of the quickest, most versatile proteins you can cook outdoors. When done right, it delivers juicy, tender meat with a light smoky char that pairs beautifully with almost any cuisine. The key is selecting the right shrimp, preparing it properly, and mastering a fast, high-heat cook—because shrimp can go from perfect to rubbery in seconds. Chef Mike Price, a New York City restaurateur and seafood expert, shares his straightforward techniques for flawless results every time.
Choosing the Right Shrimp
Start with quality. Any shrimp can be grilled, but larger sizes work best. Aim for jumbo, colossal, or 16/20 count (16–20 shrimp per pound). These bigger shrimp are easier to maneuver on the grill, stay succulent longer, and develop better caramelization.
Wild-caught shrimp from regions like the Gulf of Mexico or the Carolinas generally offer superior flavor and texture compared to farmed varieties. Look for firm flesh that appears light pink, gray, or translucent, with red gills and intact shells. Avoid any with black spots, sliminess, or off odors.
Frozen shrimp are often the freshest store option, as much “fresh” shrimp has already been thawed from frozen. If you can source live shrimp, that’s ideal—but for most home cooks, properly thawed frozen works excellently.
Preparation Essentials
Rinse the shrimp under cold water to clean them (and help thaw frozen ones). Pat them very dry with paper towels—this promotes better browning.
You can grill shrimp with or without the shell. Shell-on (or even head-on) locks in moisture and flavor, as the shell creates a natural steaming pocket. It also protects the delicate meat. Peel and devein beforehand if convenience for guests is a priority.
Toss the shrimp with a drizzle of oil (olive oil is excellent) and your chosen seasonings. Chef Price recommends bold flavors like Old Bay, garlic, ginger, curry powder, sambal, sriracha, chipotle, salt, pepper, and bright citrus such as lemon, lime, or orange. A bit of fat helps carry flavor and keeps the shrimp moist.
If marinating, keep it short—especially with acidic ingredients—to avoid over-tenderizing or “cooking” the shrimp ceviche-style. For small shrimp, thread them onto presoaked wooden or metal skewers (double-skewering prevents spinning) or use a grill basket so they don’t fall through the grates.
Grilling Step by Step
Have all your sides and serving elements ready before you begin—shrimp cook in minutes.
- Preheat the grill to 375–450°F. Clean the grates thoroughly with a wire brush and oil them well to prevent sticking. Use direct heat, whether on gas or charcoal.
- Place the shrimp directly over the heat. Cook for 1–3 minutes per side, depending on size. Flip as soon as the first side turns pink and opaque along the edges. Keep the grill lid open for better control and to avoid steaming.
- Watch closely and remove the shrimp promptly when they are fully opaque, light pink or orange, and reach an internal temperature of 145°F. They should form a loose “C” shape—not a tight “O,” which signals overcooking.
Once off the grill, spread the shrimp out on a platter rather than piling them. This prevents carryover cooking that can make them tough.
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
- Starting with frozen shrimp leads to uneven cooking and a tough exterior.
- Over-marinating in acid breaks down texture.
- Crowding the grill or walking away causes steaming or overcooking.
- Using low heat prolongs cooking time and dries out the shrimp.
Serving Suggestions
Grilled shrimp are delicious hot off the grill, at room temperature, or chilled. Serve them in tacos with grilled tortillas and lime, atop Caesar salads or risotto, in shrimp cocktails, or alongside creamy sauces and fresh herbs. They also shine in avocado salads or New England-style rolls.
Master these steps and you’ll achieve tender, flavorful grilled shrimp consistently. With practice and close attention to timing, this quick-cooking favorite will become a reliable star of your backyard meals. Fire up the grill and enjoy the results!
About The Author
