In the competitive world of pizza, few names command as much respect as Una Pizza Napoletana. Located at 175 Orchard Street in New York City’s Lower East Side, this intimate pizzeria, led by master pizzaiolo Anthony Mangieri, has repeatedly earned the title of the world’s top pizzeria according to the prestigious 50 Top Pizza rankings. It claimed the outright #1 spot globally in 2024 and has tied for first in multiple years, including 2022 and 2025, outperforming even legendary spots in Naples itself.
Anthony Mangieri’s Lifelong Obsession
Mangieri’s journey began long before the accolades. A New Jersey native from an Italian-American family with roots near Naples, he developed a deep passion for pizza during his teenage years. He studied the craft by visiting iconic pizzerias across New York, New Haven, and Italy, absorbing techniques and traditions that would shape his distinctive style.
In 1996, he opened the first Una Pizza Napoletana in Point Pleasant Beach, New Jersey. It was a small, personal operation emphasizing naturally leavened dough and wood-fired ovens. By 2004, he brought the concept to New York City’s East Village, where it quickly built a devoted cult following. Over the years, the pizzeria moved to San Francisco before returning to its current home on the Lower East Side.
What sets Mangieri apart is his uncompromising hands-on approach. He personally prepares every ball of dough, shapes each pie, applies the toppings, and bakes every pizza himself. The restaurant operates on a deliberately small scale—no large staff, no chain expansion—to preserve the highest possible quality. This singular focus has defined the pizzeria for over 25 years.
The Philosophy Behind the Perfect Pie
Una Pizza Napoletana’s success stems from a commitment to traditional Neapolitan roots, refined through decades of daily practice and instinct. The dough undergoes long fermentation using natural leavening, creating a light, digestible crust with complex flavor. Wood-fired ovens deliver the signature leopard spotting and char that define great Neapolitan pizza.
The menu remains minimal, allowing Mangieri to concentrate on perfection rather than variety. Ingredients are carefully selected for quality, and restraint in preparation lets the natural flavors shine. Reviewers consistently praise the exceptional balance, texture, and depth in every bite.
Why It Ranks #1
The 50 Top Pizza guide, often described as the “Michelin Guide of pizza,” relies on anonymous inspectors who evaluate pizzerias based on product quality, service, and atmosphere. Mangieri’s relentless attention to detail and consistency have impressed even the toughest critics. His personal involvement in every aspect of the process ensures a level of precision rarely matched in larger operations.
Beyond the rankings, Una Pizza Napoletana has earned acclaim from Michelin (Bib Gourmand), The New York Times, The New Yorker, and countless food enthusiasts. Mangieri is widely credited with helping pioneer high-end Neapolitan-style pizza in the United States.
A Singular Legacy
As of 2025–2026, Una Pizza Napoletana continues to dominate the U.S. rankings and frequently shares or claims the global top spot alongside Italy’s finest. Reservations are notoriously difficult to secure due to limited seating and overwhelming demand. While Mangieri has expanded into a frozen pizza line called Genio Della Pizza, the original restaurant remains a personal, no-frills experience where diners can watch the master at work by the oven.
Una Pizza Napoletana’s rise to the top is not the result of flashy marketing or rapid scaling. It is a story of quiet, obsessive craftsmanship sustained over decades. In an era of expansion and trends, Mangieri’s dedication to authenticity and quality proves that true excellence still resonates on the world stage—earning respect from Naples to New York. For pizza lovers, it stands as a benchmark of what the dish can achieve when made with passion and precision.
About The Author
