In Philadelphia’s Queen Village neighborhood, a red lantern hangs outside a blue door at 780 South 2nd Street. Step inside, and you enter Royal Sushi & Izakaya—a lively, dimly lit tavern buzzing with indie and old-school hip-hop playlists, clinking sake carafes, and plates of crispy karaage and yakitori. For most diners, this vibrant, walk-in neighborhood hub is the entire experience. Yet tucked behind a pair of traditional noren curtains in the back sits an entirely different world: an intimate, eight-seat sushi counter where Chef Jesse Ito serves a 17-course omakase to just 16 guests a night.
Hosted across two nightly seatings—at 6:00 PM and 8:15 PM, Tuesday through Saturday—the back-room tasting at Royal Sushi has become one of the most coveted reservations in American dining. Documented in Bon Appétit’s acclaimed series On The Line, the operation offers a rare look into the obsessive discipline, family heritage, and split-second choreography required to execute high-wire Edomae-style sushi at such an intimate scale.
A Tale of Two Restaurants
The dual structure of Royal Sushi & Izakaya was born out of hard-earned pragmatism. When Jesse Ito opened the restaurant in 2016 alongside his father, Masaharu Ito, he deliberately eliminated the traditional “middle ground” of restaurant pricing. The front izakaya was designed for volume, accessibility, and convivial energy, offering Japanese comfort food and punchy cocktails without the barrier of months-long waitlists. Behind the curtain, however, the omakase counter operates on precision, exclusivity, and uncompromising ingredient sourcing.
For Ito, this duality reflects his own upbringing. A first-generation Japanese Korean American, he grew up washing dishes at age 14 in Fuji, the beloved Cinnaminson, New Jersey restaurant his father opened in 1979. Over more than a decade working shoulder-to-shoulder with Masaharu—whom Jesse credits as his foundational teacher in knife work, fish butchery, and relentless work ethic—he learned that great hospitality is built on repetition and humility. “If you were a good dishwasher, you can be a great sushi chef,” Ito has noted, emphasizing that both roles come down to mastering systems, cleanliness, and timing.
Twelve Hours Before the First Bite
While the 16 lucky diners experience a seamless, two-hour culinary performance, the reality behind the counter begins at 10:00 AM—eight hours before the first seating. Because Royal closes on Sundays and Mondays, Tuesday prep is especially grueling, though every service day follows a strict, clock-watching rhythm.
The foundation of the entire evening is not the fish, but the rice. Every morning, Ito personally weighs, washes, and dries the grains destined for the omakase counter. Once steamed, the hot rice must be seasoned rapidly with sharizu—a proprietary blend centered around akazu, or aged red rice vinegar brewed from sake lees. Akazu imparts a subtle brownish hue and a deep, savory umami complexity that balances rich seafood. Because cooling rice turns gummy within minutes, coating every individual grain requires speed, wrist strength, and exact temperature control before the batch is transferred to a warmer.
By 10:20 AM, boxes of whole fish flown overnight from Tokyo’s famed markets arrive via JFK Airport, allocated specifically for Ito’s counter. Unlike casual sushi bars that order pre-cut fillets, Ito breaks down whole specimens from scratch—scaling, gutting, and curing fish that cost anywhere from $16 to $100 per pound. Hikarimono (silver-skinned fish) such as saba (mackerel) undergo precise salt-curing to draw out excess moisture and firm up the flesh. Later in the morning, attention turns to breaking down massive loins of Spanish bluefin tuna—often 90-pound quarter loins—separating lean akami, medium-fatty chutoro, and richly marbled otoro. Every scale must be scraped clean, every membrane trimmed, and every cut inspected; if a delivery falls short of Ito’s standards, it goes straight back to the supplier.
Composing a 17-Course Playlist
When Ito designs his 17-course progression, he does not approach it like a static restaurant menu; he treats it like sequencing an album or a workout playlist, deliberately engineering peaks, valleys, and shifts in tempo.
Service begins gently, warming the palate with otsumami (small composed dishes). A typical evening opens with chawanmushi—a silky steamed egg custard enriched with hairy crab, earthy nameko mushrooms, and clarified fish broth—followed by bright, palate-awakening bites like kanpachi (amberjack) dressed in vinegar dashi. From there, Ito gradually turns up the richness. Guests might encounter sweet red shrimp layered with scallop, uni (sea urchin), and salmon roe, or a single Kumamoto oyster topped with chopped toro tartare.
As the meal builds toward its crescendo, the nigiri courses showcase both traditional Edomae discipline and bold, unapologetic indulgence. Each piece is brushed right before serving with Ito’s house-augmented nikiri shoyu—a sweeter, seasoned soy sauce—meaning diners never need to dip their sushi or ask for extra condiments. The climax often arrives in the form of kamatoro, the ultra-rare, heavily marbled collar cut of bluefin tuna, dry-aged and marinated in soy and garlic before being crowned with creamy uni and scallions. To bring the palate back down, the meal closes on a nostalgic, comforting note: sweet, dashi-infused tamagoyaki (rolled Japanese omelet) prepared using his father Masaharu’s cherished recipe, leaving guests satisfied without feeling overwhelmed.
Intimacy Over Scale
In an era when many high-end omakase counters feel stiff, hushed, and intimidating, Royal Sushi’s back room stands apart for its warmth. Sitting mere inches from the cutting board, the eight guests per seating watch every slice of the blade and every press of Ito’s hands. There is no theatrical ego or pretentious lecturing—just direct conversation, quiet focus, and hospitality priced all-inclusively (around $300 to $355 per person with service included, so no check-splitting or tipping disrupts the spell).
Serving only 16 people a night might seem counterintuitive in a restaurant industry obsessed with table turns and expansion. In Royal’s early years, Ito pushed himself through grueling seven-day weeks and three nightly omakase seatings. Eventually, he realized that relentless volume threatened both his well-being and the soul of the craft. By capping the counter at two seatings of eight, five nights a week, Jesse Ito preserved what makes omakase—literally translated as “I leave it up to you”—truly meaningful: an unhurried, deeply personal exchange between one chef and sixteen guests.