Neymar Jr. has officially been named in Brazil’s 26-man squad for the 2026 FIFA World Cup, marking his fourth appearance in the tournament. The announcement, made by head coach Carlo Ancelotti on May 18, 2026, has ignited intense debate among fans, analysts, and former players. While some celebrate the return of Brazil’s all-time leading scorer, others argue the 34-year-old forward did not merit inclusion based on recent performances and fitness concerns.
The Case Against Neymar’s Selection
Critics point to Neymar’s limited international involvement in recent years. He has not represented Brazil since October 2023, spending much of his time recovering from a serious anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury. Although he has shown glimpses of his former brilliance at club level with Santos, his form has been described as solid rather than spectacular, especially when compared to younger Brazilian attackers competing in top European leagues.
A major flashpoint has been the omission of in-form players like Chelsea’s João Pedro, who enjoyed an outstanding season and earned individual accolades. Many believe Pedro “deserved” the spot far more on current merit, leading to accusations of favoritism and legacy bias in squad selection. Ancelotti himself admitted the decisions were difficult, expressing sympathy for those left out who “probably deserved” a place.
At 34, Neymar’s age and injury history add to the skepticism. Detractors argue that selecting him represents a gamble on past glory rather than present-day performance in a squad brimming with emerging talent.
Arguments in Favor of Inclusion
Defenders of the decision highlight Neymar’s enduring qualities beyond raw statistics. As Brazil’s record goalscorer with 79 international goals, he brings unmatched experience, creativity, and big-game pedigree to the team. Ancelotti has described him as an “important player” capable of providing the spark Brazil needs in crucial moments.
The squad already features exciting young stars such as Vinícius Jr., Endrick, and Raphinha. Neymar’s presence is seen by supporters as a valuable blend of veteran leadership and flair that could elevate the team’s chances of securing a sixth World Cup title. His name was met with widespread celebration among fans upon announcement, underscoring his iconic status in Brazilian football.
Ancelotti’s approach appears to prioritize intangibles—tactical fit, squad chemistry, and proven quality under pressure—over a purely merit-based system grounded in recent club form. Reports indicate Neymar has recovered sufficiently to contribute, making him a calculated risk worth taking.
A Timeless Football Debate
This controversy reflects a broader tension in team selection: meritocracy versus legacy and potential impact. Similar debates have surrounded veteran inclusions in past World Cups across various nations. With Brazil entering the tournament as one of the favorites, the ultimate verdict on Neymar’s selection will depend on his performances on the pitch.
Whether the gamble pays off remains to be seen when the World Cup kicks off. For now, the inclusion has divided opinions, with one side viewing it as a sentimental choice and the other as a strategic masterstroke. Football, after all, has never been decided by statistics alone.
About The Author
